Secondary and Tertiary Markets: Higher Yield, Thinner Exit


What is a secondary or tertiary commercial real estate market? A secondary market is a metro area with roughly 1 million to 4 million residents, and a tertiary market is one under 1 million, compared to a primary market's 4 million or more, a threshold CBRE uses to size retail markets nationally. Property in these smaller metros typically prices at a higher cap rate than the same building would command in a market like Dallas-Fort Worth or Houston, and that higher yield is compensation for a specific cost: fewer buyers competing for the property the day the current owner decides to sell.

Key Takeaways

  • CBRE classifies a primary market as a metro of 4 million residents or more, a secondary market as 1 million to 4 million, and a tertiary market as under 1 million.
  • Secondary and tertiary markets generally price at higher cap rates than primary markets, and that premium exists to compensate for a thinner pool of buyers at exit.
  • Institutional investors and developers face data gaps in smaller metros, which limits their presence even in secondary markets with above-average population growth.
  • A thinner buyer pool shows up concretely as fewer comparable sales for an appraiser to rely on and often a longer marketing period when the property is sold.
  • Remaining lease term and tenant credit quality compound the effect, since a short-term lease on a non-rated tenant prices both risks at the same time.
  • A higher cap rate in a smaller market is not a discount on the same asset; it is the price the market sets for accepting a narrower exit.
What Typically Changes as a Market Moves From Primary to TertiaryNotice that yield and liquidity move in opposite directions as market tier narrows.
Primary marketSecondary marketTertiary market
Metro population (CBRE threshold)4 million or more1 million to 4 millionUnder 1 million
Institutional buyer participationDeep and well coveredThinner and more selectiveShallow; data gaps limit institutional interest
Comparable sales for appraisal supportFrequent, easy to sourceFewer, with wider dispersionScarce; appraisers often lean on outside comps
Cap rate relative to a primary marketBaselineTypically higherTypically highest
Typical marketing period at exitShorter on averageLonger on averageLongest on average

Source: CBRE, Navigating Opportunities in Secondary and Tertiary Retail Markets.

What Separates a Primary Market From a Secondary or Tertiary One

A primary, secondary, or tertiary designation is a sizing convention based on population and the depth of existing commercial inventory, not a judgment about whether a given property or metro is a good investment. CBRE's retail research defines primary markets as the 13 largest markets by total supply of neighborhood, community, and strip center space, plus urban street retail in Manhattan and San Francisco, while secondary markets carry 40 million to 60 million square feet of that same space and tertiary markets carry less.

The population version of the same idea is simpler to apply across property types: a primary market is a metropolitan statistical area of 4 million residents or more, a secondary market falls between 1 million and 4 million, and a tertiary market is anything smaller. Neither definition is codified in a statute or a single industry-wide standard, which is why two research firms can classify the same metro slightly differently. What stays consistent is the underlying logic: size correlates with how many institutional buyers, how much third-party research, and how many comparable transactions exist in a given metro at any point in time.

Why Secondary and Tertiary Markets Trade at Higher Cap Rates

A property's cap rate is net operating income divided by price, and the same net lease building commands a lower price, and therefore a higher cap rate, in a smaller metro than it would in a primary one, holding the tenant and the lease identical. The Boulder Group's Q3 2026 National Net Lease Research Report put overall single tenant net lease cap rates at 6.92% nationally, with retail at 6.69%, industrial at 7.28%, and office at 8.00%, and those figures already reflect a blend of markets across every tier.

Market tier sits on top of tenant credit and lease term as a separate pricing input rather than replacing either one. A building leased to the identical national tenant, on the identical remaining term, still prices differently depending on whether it sits inside a metro with deep institutional coverage or one that smaller funds and local buyers dominate. No single published spread applies to every deal, because the premium moves with how thin the specific buyer pool for that asset type actually is in that specific metro, not with a fixed formula. What is consistent is the direction: thinner markets price at a discount to value, which is the same thing as a higher cap rate for an identical income stream.

Where the Buyer Pool Actually Thins Out

The buyer pool for commercial property narrows in a predictable order as a market gets smaller: national REITs and institutional funds concentrate in primary and the larger secondary markets first, regional funds and high-net-worth 1031 exchange buyers fill in behind them, and local operators and family offices become the dominant bidders once a metro drops into tertiary territory. CBRE's own research on secondary and tertiary retail markets states plainly that institutional investors and developers struggle with data gaps, which limits their presence and interest in smaller metros, even where retail space is scarce and demand is real.

That gap persists even when the underlying growth story is strong. Secondary markets often carry above-average population and job growth, which is part of what attracts capital to them in the first place, but growth and institutional coverage are not the same thing. A metro can be adding households and retailers faster than a mature primary market while still lacking the transaction volume, the third-party appraisals, and the research coverage that let an institutional buyer underwrite with confidence. That mismatch between growth and buyer depth is a large part of why the premium exists at all.

Why the Exit Takes Longer

A thinner buyer pool reaches an owner at the moment of sale through two concrete mechanisms: fewer comparable transactions for an appraiser to rely on, and fewer lenders actively quoting debt on a deal of that size in that location. An appraisal in a primary market can draw on several recent, similar sales nearby. An appraisal in a tertiary market frequently has to stretch the comparable set across a wider geography or lean on primary-market sales as a proxy, which introduces judgment into a step that a deeper market settles with data.

Financing follows the same pattern. Life insurance companies and CMBS lenders tend to compete hardest for stabilized, primary-market deals above a certain size, while smaller regional banks and credit unions fill the gap in secondary and tertiary markets, often at a narrower range of terms. Fewer lenders bidding for the same loan generally means less competitive pricing on the debt side, which compounds the lower pricing already showing up on the equity side. The combined result is a longer expected marketing period at sale, since the pool of parties who can both find the deal and finance it is smaller to begin with.

How Tenant Credit and Lease Term Interact With Market Tier

Market tier does not operate in isolation from the other two variables that set a net lease cap rate, tenant credit and remaining lease term, and the three compound rather than average out. The Boulder Group's own net lease research describes the bid-ask spread between buyers and sellers as narrowest for long-term, investment-grade assets and widest for below-investment-grade or non-rated tenants with five years or fewer remaining on the primary term, which is the same pattern that governs market tier, applied to credit and duration instead of geography.

A long lease to a national, investment-grade tenant in a tertiary market is a genuinely different asset than a short remaining term on a non-rated operator in that same market, even though both carry the tertiary-market discount. The first is a buyer pool problem layered on top of an otherwise clean credit story. The second stacks a buyer pool problem on top of a credit problem and a renewal problem at the same time, which is why cap rates in smaller markets show more dispersion than cap rates in primary markets for the identical property type. Reading market tier as one input among several, rather than the only input, is what keeps the analysis honest.

What This Means for Texas and Sun Belt Investors

Texas and the broader Sun Belt contain all three tiers inside a single region, which makes the distinction concrete rather than abstract for anyone evaluating Texas commercial real estate investing across its own metros. Dallas-Fort Worth and Houston sit comfortably inside CBRE's primary-market population threshold, while metros in the 1 million to 4 million range fall into the secondary tier, and a long list of smaller Texas and Sun Belt cities sit below that line entirely.

The same caution about population growth as an underwriting input applies directly here: a smaller Sun Belt metro adding residents and rooftops quickly is not automatically building the institutional buyer depth that a primary market already has. Growth changes what a property's income is likely to do over a hold period. It does not, by itself, change how many buyers show up to bid on that property when the hold period ends. Those are two separate questions, and conflating them is a common mistake when a strong growth chart gets read as a liquidity promise it never made.

Freedom Commercial Real Estate publishes guides like this one so investors can separate a market's growth story from its exit liquidity before they ever look at a specific property. Questions about anything covered here, or a market mechanic worth explaining next, can go straight to the team at info@freedomcre.net.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How much higher are cap rates in secondary and tertiary markets compared to primary markets?

A: There is no single published spread that applies to every deal, because the premium depends on the specific property type, tenant credit, and lease term as well as the metro itself. The Boulder Group's Q3 2026 research put overall single tenant net lease cap rates at 6.92% nationally, a figure that already blends every market tier; a specific secondary or tertiary deal can price meaningfully above or below that blended number depending on its own facts.

Q: Does strong population growth in a secondary market mean the buyer pool is as deep as a primary market's?

A: Not necessarily. CBRE's own research notes that institutional investors and developers face data gaps that limit their presence in smaller metros, even where population and job growth run above average. Growth supports a property's income over time; it does not automatically supply the transaction volume and research coverage that deepen a buyer pool.

Q: Why do appraisers sometimes use primary-market comparable sales for a tertiary-market property?

A: Because tertiary markets generally produce fewer transactions of a similar size and property type nearby, which can leave an appraiser without enough local comparables to support a value conclusion on local sales alone. Stretching the comparable set to a wider geography, or to a primary market, is a common workaround, and it is one reason valuations in thinner markets carry more judgment than valuations in deeper ones.

Q: Is a higher cap rate in a secondary or tertiary market a better deal for an investor?

A: Not automatically. A higher cap rate in a smaller market is generally compensation for a thinner buyer pool, fewer comparable sales, and less competitive financing at the eventual exit, not a discount on an otherwise identical asset. Whether the additional yield is worth the additional illiquidity depends on the specific tenant, lease, and holding period, and is not a question a market-tier label can answer on its own.

Sources

Have a question about what you just read? Freedom Commercial Real Estate publishes these guides as investor education. Send the team your question, or keep reading below.

This article is for informational purposes only and is not an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security, nor investment, tax, or legal advice. Any offering is made only through official offering documents to verified accredited investors. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Keep Reading

More Insights

Gas and Convenience Real Estate: Why Fuel Sites Trade on Different Math

A gas station and convenience store is a net lease asset with a buried complication: the tanks underneath it carry environmental liability that an ordinary retail box never has. Here is how underground storage tanks, Phase I site assessments, and brand-by-brand credit differences actually change the underwriting.

Population Growth as an Underwriting Input, Not a Talking Point

A metro population figure is a statistic until four things are attached to it: a geography, a component of change, a vintage, and the revenue line it is claimed to move. Here is how each one is checked, and what the Census data can and cannot support.